Independent specialists

Six required criteria

Every assignment requires current evidence of qualifications, experience, specialist expertise and independence.

Specialist selection, explained

Qualifications. Experience. Independence.

What makes a specialist suitable, how conflicts of interest are checked and who takes personal responsibility for the medical assessment.

More about independence
Open video ↗
Illustrative scene: two people in neutral clinical clothing review documents together.

Documented evidence and independent checks

Expertise is verified.

Before assigning a specialist, we check qualifications, experience, specialist expertise and independence.

  1. Verified specialist qualification

    Qualifications and their current validity must be supported by evidence.

  2. At least ten years of relevant practice

    The experience must be relevant to the specific area under review.

  3. Relevant subspecialist expertise

    Assignment is based on the particular case and procedure.

  4. Independence from the patient's treatment history

    The specialist must not have treated the patient previously.

  5. Independence from the provider under review

    Financial, personal and professional relationships are checked before assignment.

  6. Separation of review and treatment

    The specialist does not treat this case during the review or for six months after it is completed.

Procedure-specific experience

Qualifications must fit the context

Illustrative scene: a doctor reads unlabelled documents in a quiet workspace.

Traceable sources

Every claim needs a source.

Public information is considered only when its source and review date can be traced.

Illustrative scene: clinical professionals review generic images before a possible procedure.

Relevance to the procedure

Experience must match the subject of the review.

Titles alone are not enough. Evidence of active practice, relevant specialist expertise and current professional work is considered separately.

Illustrative scene: an interdisciplinary team reviews unlabelled documents.

Depth of review

Specific questions require a separate engagement.

Before the review begins, you can see its scope, the responsible doctor and the consent required.

Illustrative scene: clinical professionals review generic images on an unlabelled monitor.

Imaging records

Understanding images in context.

Generic images are considered alongside the question, their source and other records to establish the relevant context.